Sunday, July 24, 2011

A Great Tour at a Great Time

There is no doubt the sport of professional cycling has taken a PR beating over the last 13 years. Once the Festina affair of '98 blew the lid off of the seedy underbelly of doping in the sport, there has been a cloud hanging over it's biggest event, the Tour de France. Just when it seems that things are getting better, Operation Puerto happens, or race leaders/winners like Floyd Landis and Alberto Contador test positive. While cycling is undergoing a cleansing, the Tour got just what it needed this year: a spectacular race with a worthy champion and no doping controversies.

At age 34, Cadel Evans became the third oldest man to ever win the Tour, and the first Aussie (somewhere Phil Anderson is smiling). He's been trying for years, twice finishing second. I used to not be much of an Evans fan, but ever since he won the World Championship with that brilliant attack in Mendrisio, I've come around on him. He'll now go down in the record books as one of the sport's greatest, an all-around champion who can win the biggest one-day events, as well as the hardest stage races. You wouldn't guess it by looking at his slight build and hearing his contralto voice, but Evans proved to be one of the toughest men on earth over the past three weeks.

Evans won this race as the greats of the past have, with consistency and panache. He won stage four by out-sprinting Contador on a steep, uphill finish. He was always near the front on the big climbs, often having to work alone without the benefit of teammate...or a brother (I loved that the Schlecks were always trying to give Evans the old one-two, yet Evans still prevailed) in the high mountains. His rivals refused to help him chase, so Evans just got on with the task at hand and did it all himself. He kept himself close enough to the lead throughout the three weeks, and then finished everyone off with one of the most dominant time trial rides in recent Tour history.

To win the Tour, you must be a complete rider. You must be able to ride with the best uphill, downhill, and in the time trials. Evans can do all three. Andy Schleck can only do one of those. Granted, he does that one thing (climb) better than anyone, but it wasn't enough. Andy lost the Tour on the descents and in the time trials. Andy didn't ride a poor final time trial when he surrendered yellow to Evans, it just wasn't the kind of TT a Tour champion has to ride. The pure climbers who have won the Tour in the last 30 years (Delgado, Pantani, Sastre) have all been able to go downhill fast, as well as ride a competent enough time trial to hold on to the race lead.

Andy Schleck: The New Poulidor?

It should be noted that Andy Schleck is getting better at riding against the clock. His ride in this year's final TT was not as poor as everyone is making out to be: he finished 17th, 2:38 back. Compare that to his final TT last year, when he finished 44th and 6:12 back. Yet everyone says he rode a great TT last year and a poor one this year. In reality, it's just the opposite. What confuses everyone is that Contador rode a very poor TT last year, making Andy's ride look good. But Contador was terrible that day, as was Schleck. This year, Schleck was OK, Evans was phenomenal. OK usually doesn't win the Tour. Phenomenal does.

Will Andy Schleck ever win the Tour? He's finished second three times now. He's 26, so he's got many good years remaining. He's got to get over his shakes going down hill fast, and he's got become a better time trialist. He's clearly got a massive engine, so he should be able to ride faster against the clock. But I can't see him ever being a truly complete rider. Plus, he'll have to face Contador in his prime for a few more years. Andy might get a Tour win at some point, but he's had two golden chances the last two years, and he couldn't do it. How many more golden chances will he get?

Raymond Poulidor earned the nickname "The Eternal Second" because he was always close to winning the Tour, but never did. My guess is that Andy Schleck's career will look more like Joop Zoetemelk's or Jan Ullrich's: a lot of second place finishes, but one Tour win sandwiched somewhere in the middle.

Best Tour in Years

Credit to Tour Director Christian Prudhomme for laying out a great course. The team time trial is always fun. The first week wasn't just a bunch of boring, flat sprint finales--there were plenty of tricky and tough uphill finishes to make it interesting. The second week in the Pyrenees was great, unfortunately the riders rode the stages very conservatively which made for some dull mountain racing. But they more than made up for it in week three. There were more fireworks in the Alps than we've had in some time. The early stages in week three were made interesting by the tricky descents that ended stages and created time gaps. The two big stages ending on the Galibier and l'Alpe d'Huez were brutal tests, and Schleck and Contador attacking so far from the finish on those days were the stuff of legend.

Speaking of Contador, he was never really himself in this Tour. Why? He probably never thought he would get to race the Tour (his doping hearing was supposed to take place in June), so he raced all-out at the Tour of Italy in May, which he won in dominant fashion. He may not have left much in the tank for July. Or, perhaps he lost too much time because of crashes in the first week. Or, maybe this is the real, non doped-up Contador, who, when clean, is one of the best in the world, but not always the best. Whatever the reason, a below-his-best Contador was still a big part of the race. He helped make it an epic Tour.

French interest in the race was sky-high. Thomas Voeckler's long stint in the yellow jersey was tremendous to watch--he fought as hard as anyone in recent memory to stay in the lead, and kept the jersey much longer than anyone (including himself) thought was possible. It's amazing to consider that in his career, Voeckler has now worn the maillot jaune for 20 days, more than Fausto Coppi, Felice Gimondi, Alberto Contador, or Jan Ullrich. Thomas Voeckler! Teammate Pierre Rolland was a revelation, winning the white jersey for best young rider, as well as the stage to l'Alpe d'Huez. Two other French riders finished in the top 15. For a country that hasn't had a Tour winner since Hinault in '85, the future is finally looking bright.

There were so many other great animators in this race. Mark Cavendish won five stages (20 now in just four years!). The world champ Thor Hushovd won two stages and did the rainbow jersey proud. Fellow Norwegian Edvald Boasson Hagen won two stages as well, and looks like a future superstar. Philippe Gilbert was always mixing it up. Even American Tyler Farrar got his first-ever Tour stage win, while his American team Garmin-Cervelo won the best team competition.

Vive Le Tour

I was reminded of why this is the greatest sporting event in the world. Three weeks of incredible suffering, incredible sports drama, and incredible performances. Three weeks of getting to listen to Phil Liggett. Three weeks of all kinds of weather. Three weeks of crashes and sprints. And, three weeks of HD television pictures of the most beautiful stadium ever created: the French countryside (sorry Jerry, it's even more amazing than your Deathstar--as if he's reading this blog).

Perhaps most importantly, this appeared to be a clean Tour. It looked like the old days of cycling--riders looking exhausted at the end of a tough stage, star riders getting dropped on the climbs, and riders attacking from way out in an attempt to make up lost time. In many ways it was a throw-back Tour. We saw the kind of racing we haven't seen since the 80's--since before EPO. Maybe the great lengths the sport has gone to in order to clean up the peloton are finally working. Maybe.

If a Cadel Evans positive drug test is revealed in the next few days, forget I wrote any of this.


  1. Cadel has two second places (one to contador, the other to sastre) to his first win this year. Can he win again? At 34, I'm not sure. What will be his legacy? I know andy will win eventually, at 26 his future is a lot brighter than Cadel's is.

  2. How did Cadel get a hot Italian model with that voice of his? I guess the answer is always the

  3. David S. in PlanoJuly 24, 2011 at 2:17 PM

    A tilt of the old hat to Cadel! What a Great race this year. I was rooting for Andy to win all along, but Cadel never faded and always kept himself in the mix. He distinguished himself as the true champion this year. The top riders all rode hard in the Alps, but Cadel seemed to have just a little more in reserve for the time trial. Voeckler's determination and combativeness while in yellow will be talked about for years to come Viva La Tour!

  4. Chapeau to the Tour de France this year, it delivered!

    This year, for me, also produced another 'Joe Theismann' can't-watch-that moment with the French TV vs. Johnny Hoogerland crash which sent the latter into a barbed-wire fence at a pretty high rate of speed. Suffering, indeed, but not the way they usually script it.

    Team RadioShack had a miserable tour and I wonder what they will take out of it. Even after the crashes, they could not even manage to get any headlines as breakaway participants.

    Thanks for the great blog coverage, Craig.

  5. I too started the Tour on the Schleck bandwagon. After chaingate I was dead set on rooting against "the evil" Contador. However after watching Andy complain about the descents so close to the finish I had to find another champion and Evans was the only logical choice. I hope Andy matures and gets it right soon. But until he becomes a complete rider we'll have Contador. I'm so sad it's over but I'll at least be able to get off the couch and ride now.

  6. How much does a typical bike weigh that was used in the Tour de France? And for more punishment, why don't they take the seat off just to make them dance 100% on the pedals throughout the entire stage?

  7. Minimum bike weight = 15lbs.

  8. Great blog Craig! I have really enjoyed your coverage of the tour and blogs. I have to admit - I did not think I'd enjoy this year's tour without Lance. But - this was amazing - so very happy with the top 3 finishers. Can't wait till next year - I'm hoping for an overdue win by Andy Schleck.

  9. I am not the biggest fan of Frandy Schleck, but Andy almost brought me around with that ride on Friday. Whether you like him or not, the guy put the hammer down. Voeckler rode an amazing race. Watching him get dropped on Friday, yelling at his teammates to slow down was so hard to watch. No one would've faulted him if he'd sat up and slid back into the peloton, conceding the jersey to Schleck. But he didn't. He kept riding. The guy was incredible.

    I really hope this was a clean(er) Tour and I hope we get more just like this.

    @Anonymous 7:17pm UCI regulations on bikes is 6.9 kilos or about 15.2 lbs.

  10. I thought of the Tour when you were discussing your adopting Soccer as a new sport. My wife and I started watching the tour several years ago due to Armstrong (and the fact that she likes to bike). We've become fans of the tour and look forward to the 3 weeks every summer.

  11. Great blog Craig. In that 3rd paragraph, isn't "panache" some kind of new banned substance?

  12. Awesome work Craig!!! I always enjoy your comments on the Tour... I am french and used to go see it live. Now, I watch it on TV and read your blog and others. Keep it up!